Are Black Holes Solitons? A Deep Dive into Physics
Summary
The FriendZone | Make Friends & Chat ⋅ Active Social Fun ⋅ Chill ⋅ VC server is hosting a deep-dive discussion on the nature of black holes. This announcement challenges traditional singularity models, proposing that particles are non-linear solitons within a universal medium. By exploring phase transitions and the Bekenstein limit, the community is invited to debate complex physics topics in a chill, social environment.
Treatment of particles as point objects / excitations of a field [in case of field theories], without a doubt introduces the dilemma of singularities, and infinite densities, and other properties like self energy, etc. It would not be surprising if the current understanding of black holes is limited by virtue of the same assumptions.
The very reason we see black holes as singularities is because we try to compress particles to occupy the same place [something not allowed per Q.M., even theories like LQG suggest that is not the case]. When in reality, particles can easily be non linear solitons embedded in the fabric of a universal medium, and thus have a finite size, and a winding.
Isn't it interesting, that such a topology will have an elastic limit, beyond which it could not be twisted further / have a higher winding ?
Perhaps black holes are phase transitions, to a region of the medium which has been distorted to its limit thanks to holding the maximum amount of solitons without tearing it apart, maximally entangled clusters of solitons.
An interesting emergent property here, would be, that solitons in larger clusters will represent a higher entropy, and if the universe can allow only large enough clusters within a space, beyond which it would not be possible to protect the topology, does it not sound similar to the Bekenstein limit of entropy ?
Further, a winding so strong may lead to divergent torsional gradients, if light is the Goldstone mode / boson with zero winding, that is, just a disturbance, it would topologically not be able to go across it from either side. Have we tried to explore this in conjunction with Verlinde's thermodynamic derivation of the field equations ?
If we introduce coloured noise within the medium, perhaps Hawking's Radiation may be solvable as well ?
We need such theories without being hindered by obvious non linearity.
No limit to the larp
Thanks for adding nothing to the discussion.
Wise words in Discord its a dream I think
That is very interesting
Hmmm
Genuinely define entropy for me bro i feel like ur larping in your own words not some ai bs lol
Entropy is, at its most basic, a measure of disorder.
This disorder is not about how messy a system looks.
It is a measure of how many possible states a system can be in, given some specific constraints. It is not a one-look at a system and deduction of whether it looks messy or structured, but about analyzing, that out of how many states, it exists in this specific one.
At an atomic scale, it is about quanta / energy packets. For a specific molecular level lattice, or even a molecule, it's bonds have specific energies, that can shift and move through the structure.
If you fix the total energy, disorder is then measured as how many possible unique configurations exist, and how probable it is.
As the system keeps on shifting energies, but you'll [obviously] find the most probable one at most times.
The total possible configurations is the entropy, and the most probable state is what exists most likely.
Think of an ideal gas in a closed vessel. You will almost never find all the molecules in one half of it.
The total possible arrangements of gas molecules is astronomically large, out of those, an extremely small amount are those in which molecules are in one half.
We don't see such weird things on our scale, because the most probable macrostate is too, too likely. But on much, much smaller scales, the numbers are smaller, and so is the edge that the most likely state has.
The reason ideal gases expand, is because if you increase the vessel volume, it just gets more possible configurations to exist in, thus, it expands. Obviously, solids do not, because here intermolecular forces are against increasing entropy and breaking high energy bonds, it depends on how strong the entropy change will be versus how much energy you need. Any process where either both agree, or one is stronger, becomes spontaneous.
By the way, yes, I wrote that myself, LLMs or AIs are abominable in such matters where you criticize mainstream Physics.
yeah keep going, I'm almost finished.
It's all over the screen, type shit.
Not my proudest jerk, but I made it work.
Fairs how old r u
U give off 15 yr old vibes
No, I'm actually 9.
Amazing 👏
Not on some judgemental shi btw js curious as to why ur like this lol
larping kurtzgezagt
